GenderID.nl

A belief · not a fact · critically examined

Home › Research › Regret rates

Regret figures and methodological problems

"Only 1% regret their transition": this figure, often cited to reassure patients before an irreversible intervention, comes from the meta-analysis by Bustos et al. (2021). It concerns people who underwent gender-affirming surgery, and its own authors point to the great subjectivity of assessing regret and the lack of standardised questionnaires (source). The Cass Review (2024) for its part writes that the proportion of people who regret or detransition is hard to establish from clinic data alone (source).

The Bustos study

Bustos et al. (2021) carried out a meta-analysis of 27 studies covering 7,928 people who underwent gender-affirming surgery; the pooled prevalence of regret was 1% (source). The authors themselves note the subjectivity of assessing regret and the lack of standardised questionnaires.

Problem 1 — people lost to follow-up

According to the Cass Review, people who detransition do not necessarily return to the gender clinic and are therefore lost to follow-up; this makes it hard to estimate from clinic data alone the proportion who regret or detransition (source). The Dutch Health Council (2026) notes that in studies of regret follow-up is usually short and attrition substantial, and that some of those who stop or regret do not report it to their care providers (source). In Littman's (2021) online survey of 100 self-selected detransitioners, only 24% had told their clinicians that they had detransitioned; the sample is not representative of all detransitioners (source).

Problem 2 — follow-up is far too short

According to clinicians from adult gender services cited in the Cass Review, the time to detransition is 5 to 10 years; studies with shorter follow-up cannot capture it. A Tavistock audit of 40 patients who detransitioned found a time of 5 to 10 years (mean 7 years). In addition, the rise in referrals of children and adolescents has its inflection point in 2014: even studies with long follow-up do not cover this more recent cohort (source).

Problem 3 — a narrow definition of regret

In some studies "regret" is measured by a narrow indicator, such as an application to revert to the original legal sex: the Swedish study by Dhejne et al. (2014) thus counts 15 "regret applications", or 2.2% of those who had obtained a new legal status, with a significant decline over the decades (source). Such a measure captures neither people who stop treatment without informing the clinic, nor those who stop hormones while continuing to identify as transgender or non-binary, as the Cass Review also notes (source).

Problem 4 — the wrong population

The most cited studies largely concern cohorts of adults followed before the sharp rise in referrals of children and adolescents, whose inflection point lies in 2014; the proportion of people registered female at birth among those referred to gender services has increased (source). For this more recent population it is not yet known how frequent regret and detransition will be. See also detransition research .

More nuanced figures

Depending on the definition and population, published figures vary:

  • Dhejne et al. (2014, Archives of Sexual Behavior): 15 applications to revert to the original legal sex, or 2.2% of those who obtained a new legal status in Sweden between 1960 and 2010 (source).
  • Hall et al. (2021, BJPsych Open): 12 people (6.9%) met the definition of detransition among 175 people discharged from a UK adult clinic (source).
  • Boyd et al. (2022, Healthcare): in a general practice audit in England, eight of the 41 patients on hormones (20%) stopped them after a mean of five years (source).
  • Roberts et al. (2022, JCEM): of 952 young people and young adults in the US Military Health System, 70.2% were still on hormones after four years; the study does not measure regret (source).
  • Littman (2021): of 100 self-recruited detransitioners, 55% felt they had not received an adequate evaluation before transition, and 24% had told their clinicians that they had detransitioned; these results are not representative of all detransitioners (source).

A more detailed discussion with methodological analysis is available at transgenderidentiteit.nl — how often does it really occur and at transitieschade.nl/detrans/cijfers . As long as clinics do not follow patients up, the 1% narrative will keep circulating.

Why the gap between the figures matters

Whether one takes 1% or a considerably higher figure changes the balance of benefits and risks. The current data do not settle it: the Cass Review concludes that there is no good evidence on the long-term outcomes of interventions to manage gender-related distress, and that the frequency of regret and detransition is hard to establish (source).

What detransitioners themselves say

The surveys of detransitioners by Littman (2021, 100 respondents) and Vandenbussche (2022, 237 respondents) are based on self-selected samples and are not representative of all detransitioners. Littman's respondents cite, among other things, becoming more comfortable with their birth sex (60%), concerns about medical complications (49%) and the belief that their gender dysphoria had a specific cause such as trauma, abuse or a mental health condition (38%); 23% mention homophobia or difficulty accepting themselves as lesbian, gay or bisexual (source). Portraits of Keira Bell, Chloe Cole, Helena Kerschner, Prisha Mosley, Sinead Watson and Walt Heyer are available at transitieschade.nl/detrans .

Irreversible regret

Some consequences of medical treatment are irreversible.

  • Mastectomy: removal of the glandular breast tissue; breastfeeding is no longer possible afterwards (see irreversible loss of breast tissue).
  • Fertility: cross-sex hormones can affect fertility, and gonadectomy permanently rules out reproduction; the University of York review for the Cass Review found only limited or inconsistent evidence on the effect of puberty blockers on fertility. The Cass Review recommends that everyone be offered fertility counselling (recommendation 10) (source), and WPATH 8 (statement 6.10) asks that adolescents be informed about possible loss of fertility before any treatment (source). See also infertility after hormones and surgery.

The political use

The claim "99% have no regret" should not be presented to patients as a certainty: the Cass Review writes that the frequency of regret and detransition is hard to establish from clinic data alone (source), which affects the quality of informed consent. See also publication bias.

Sources

  1. Bustos, V.P. et al. (2021). Regret after Gender-affirmation Surgery: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Prevalence. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery Global Open . europepmc.org
  2. Dhejne, C. et al. (2014). An analysis of all applications for sex reassignment surgery in Sweden, 1960–2010: prevalence, incidence, and regrets. Archives of Sexual Behavior . europepmc.org
  3. Vandenbussche, E. (2021). Detransition-Related Needs and Support: A Cross-Sectional Online Survey. Journal of Homosexuality .
  4. Littman, L. (2021). Individuals Treated for Gender Dysphoria with Medical and/or Surgical Transition Who Subsequently Detransitioned. Archives of Sexual Behavior . pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
  5. Boyd, I., Hackett, T., Bewley, S. (2022). Care of Transgender Patients: A General Practice Quality Improvement Approach. Healthcare, 10(1), 121. europepmc.org
  6. Hall, R., Mitchell, L., Sachdeva, J. (2021). Access to care and frequency of detransition among a cohort discharged by a UK national adult gender identity clinic. BJPsych Open . europepmc.org
  7. Roberts, C.M. et al. (2022). Continuation of Gender-affirming Hormones Among Transgender Adolescents and Adults. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism . europepmc.org
  8. Gezondheidsraad (2026). Transgenderzorg voor jongeren (advies nr. 2026/12). gezondheidsraad.nl
  9. Smeehuijzen, Smids, Hoekstra (2023). Transgenderzorg aan kinderen. Nederlands Juristenblad 2023/1772, nr. 25. njb.nl
  10. Cass, H. (2024). Independent Review of Gender Identity Services for Children and Young People. NHS England.
  11. Vasterman, P. & Kuitenbrouwer, J. (28 April 2024). Dutch protocol in transgenderzorg is onhoudbaar. NRC.

See also

External sources in the network