Home › Research › Desistance
Desistance: what follow-up studies say about children with gender dysphoria
A much-discussed finding about childhood gender dysphoria is that, in the older follow-up studies, it did not persist into adulthood in most children referred before puberty. Most of them became gay or bisexual adults. These studies have been criticised, among other things because not all children had a formal diagnosis, and they say little about the young people who present today; according to the systematic review for the Cass Review, no conclusions can be drawn about the effect of puberty blockers (source).
What desistance is
Desistance — the spontaneous disappearance of gender dysphoria in adolescence without medical intervention. The term comes from the clinical literature; the best-known follow-up studies come from Canada (Toronto) and the Netherlands (Amsterdam).
The figures
- Steensma et al. (2013) — 127 young people referred in childhood (under 12): the stronger the gender dysphoria in childhood, the greater the likelihood of persistence; the likelihood was higher in natal girls.
- Wallien & Cohen-Kettenis (2008) — 77 referred children: at age 16 or older, 43% were no longer gender dysphoric, 27% still were and 30% could not be reached or traced.
- Drummond et al. (2008) — 25 girls: in 3 (12%) gender dysphoria was still present at follow-up.
- Singh et al. (2021) — 139 boys: 87.8% desisted; 36.7% of the boys did not meet the full diagnostic criteria in childhood.
According to the Cass Review, in earlier studies gender incongruence persisted into adulthood in about 15% of children referred before puberty; in later studies of children who did meet the diagnostic criteria, the figure was between 10% and 33% (source).
What most desisters become
According to the Cass Review, most of these children grew up to be gay or bisexual adults without a transgender identity (source). The figures differ by study: among the boys in the Toronto study (Singh et al. 2021), 63.6% of participants, including the persisters, reported a bisexual or androphilic orientation in fantasy; among the girls (Drummond et al. 2008), 32% were gay or bisexual in fantasy; in the Amsterdam study (Wallien & Cohen-Kettenis 2008), among the desisters all girls were heterosexual and about half of the boys were gay or bisexual.
The activist objection examined
Critics argue that desistance figures are outdated or mixed up with "merely gender-nonconforming behaviour". That criticism is partly justified: in the studies by Singh et al. (2021) and Drummond et al. (2008), 36.7% and 40% of the children respectively did not meet the full diagnostic criteria in childhood, and the Cass Review also mentions this criticism of the first studies. Later studies of children who did meet the criteria found persistence of 10% to 33%. See also ROGD research, detransition figures and the Zhou brain study.
Social transition closes the exit
According to the Cass Review, the great majority of young people who start puberty blockers go on to hormones (source). In the study by Steensma et al. (2013), social transition in childhood predicted persistence of gender dysphoria in natal boys — an association, not proof of cause. The Cass Review calls social transition an active intervention that may change the course of identity development, but also writes that because the research is weak, much is unknown (source). See also criticism of the Dutch Protocol .
What this means
According to the older studies, some of the children referred before puberty grow out of it. According to the systematic review for the Cass Review, no conclusions can be drawn about the effect of puberty blockers on gender dysphoria and mental health (source). What played a part in the closure of Tavistock is described in that article.
The classic figures concern childhood dysphoria. For adolescent Rapid-Onset Gender Dysphoria — see Littman 2018 — no comparable follow-up figures are known; according to the Cass Review, there is no good evidence on the long-term outcomes of interventions for gender-related distress.
WPATH SOC 8 also discusses the persistence studies and, for social transition of children, advises extra attention to children who consistently and often persistently express a gender identity that does not match the sex registered at birth. The Cass Review describes the persistence figures (about 15% in earlier studies, 10% to 33% in later studies) and points to the criticism of the first studies.
No. "Doing nothing" and waiting for natural development is precisely not an active therapy. According to the Cass Review, social transition is an active intervention, because it can have significant effects on psychological functioning and longer-term outcomes; Cass calls the evidence base for the care of these young people "an area of remarkably weak evidence".
Sources
- Wallien, M.S.C. & Cohen-Kettenis, P.T. (2008). Psychosexual outcome of gender-dysphoric children. Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18981931
- Steensma, T. et al. (2013). Factors associated with desistence and persistence of childhood gender dysphoria. JAACAP .
- Singh, D. et al. (2021). A follow-up study of boys with gender identity disorder. Frontiers in Psychiatry . europepmc.org/article/MED/33854450
- Drummond, K.D. et al. (2008). A follow-up study of girls with gender identity disorder. Developmental Psychology. europepmc.org/article/MED/18194003