GenderID.nl

A belief · not a fact · critically examined

Home › Identities › Trans Woman

Trans woman

"Trans woman" refers to someone of male sex at birth who identifies as a woman. Clinical research long distinguished two different groups. Critics argue that this distinction disappears in current information, although it matters for care, research and policy.

Definition according to proponents

Someone of male sex at birth who identifies as a woman, with or without hormones or surgery.

Origin: Blanchard's two routes

In the late 1980s Ray Blanchard distinguished two groups: (1) homosexual transsexualism, with early onset, feminine behaviour from childhood and attraction to men; (2) autogynephilia, with later onset, sexual arousal at the thought of oneself as a woman and usually a heterosexual history. See Blanchard typology and autogynephilia.

Researchers such as J. Michael Bailey and Anne Lawrence support the typology; others, including Julia Serano and Charles Moser, dispute it. DSM-5 lists autogynephilia as a specifier of transvestic disorder.

Criticism: clinically different groups merged

Critics argue that merging clinically different groups distorts research and policy. A Swedish register study (Dhejne et al., 2011) found higher mortality after sex reassignment, mainly from suicide, and saw that male-to-female individuals retained the male pattern in crime rates (source).

The claim that trans women are women rests on the concept of gender identity. There is no measurable marker that confirms or refutes the claim; the only source is self-report. See also circular reasoning and unfalsifiability. See also biological sex.

Sport and treatment

According to the review by Hilton and Lundberg (2021), testosterone suppression typically reduces muscle mass and strength by about 5 percent after twelve months, so most of the male advantage remains (source). Medical pathways include oestrogens, breast augmentation and vaginoplasty. See detransition research.

Related identities

Frequently Asked Questions

Sources

  1. Blanchard, R. (1989). The classification and labeling of nonhomosexual gender dysphorias. Archives of Sexual Behavior .
  2. Bailey, J. M. (2003). The Man Who Would Be Queen . National Academies Press.
  3. Lawrence, A. (2013). Men Trapped in Men's Bodies . Springer.
  4. Hilton, E. & Lundberg, T. (2021). Transgender women in elite sports. Sports Medicine , 51.
  5. Biggs, M. (2022). The transition from sex to gender in English prisons. Journal of Controversial Ideas , 2(1).

See also