Home › Identities › Genderfluid
Gender fluid
"Genderfluid" is the self-description of people whose sense of gender changes over time. Critics point out that this clashes with the original view of gender identity as an early-formed, stable core; supporters see fluctuation as part of the identity.
Definition according to proponents
An identity in which the sense of gender varies over time — from day to day or phase to phase. The change may run between male and female or through non-binary positions.
Origin
The term spread from the 2010s via Tumblr and YouTube — see the spread since 2010. Reliable figures on how often the label is used are lacking. Lisa Littman (2018) described the hypothesis that gender identification in some adolescents is linked to friend groups and social media (source); see Littman/ROGD.
Criticism: a core that changes
Robert Stoller described "core gender identity" as an early-formed, largely fixed core. Critics argue that a sense of gender that changes by the day or period does not fit that, and that genderfluid thus exposes a tension in the model. See also performative speech act.
There is no measurable marker that confirms or refutes the claim; the only source is self-report. See also circular reasoning and unfalsifiability.
Kathleen Stock (Material Girls, 2021) criticises the theory that gender identity should weigh more heavily in society than biological sex. Levine, Abbruzzese and Mason (2022) discuss the problems of informed consent for young people who identify as trans.
What the sources say about treatment
The Cass Review (2024) calls care for young people with gender dysphoria "an area of remarkably weak evidence" and writes that only three guidelines address the treatment of non-binary young people: the Swedish and Norwegian ones do not recommend hormone treatment for this group because of a lack of evidence, whereas WPATH does recommend tailored hormone treatment (source). SBU (2022) found the evidence insufficient to assess the effects of puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones (source). See also detransition research.
Related identities
Gender flux — intensity variation within the same idea.
Bigender — two genders, often alternating.
Non-binary — an umbrella under which genderfluid often falls.
Frequently Asked Questions
Only through self-report; there is no external marker.
Not necessarily. Bigender is about two genders at once or alternately, genderfluid about change; the boundary depends on self-definition.
Critics see a tension with the idea of a stable inner core. See unfalsifiable.
Sources
- Marchiano, L. (2017). Outbreak: On Transgender Teens and Psychic Epidemics. Psychological Perspectives . tandfonline.com .
- Stock, K. (2021). Material Girls .