GenderID.nl

A belief · not a fact · critically examined

Three German states want to fix self-identification law after two embarrassing cases

Since November 2024, anyone in Germany has been able to change their registered sex and first name at the civil registry office by simply notifying a civil registry official: no doctor, no expert assessment, no judge overseeing the process. The Selbstbestimmungsgesetz was intended to give transgender people a quick and dignified route. Less than two years later, that same route was suspected of having been used for very different purposes in two high-profile cases — and this prompted three German states to propose changes.

What the law actually regulates

The Selbstbestimmungsgesetz (SBGG) replaced the old Transsexuellengesetz and removed the requirements that were still part of it: no more psychological assessment, judicial review or medical certificate. A notification to the civil registry office is sufficient, followed by a three-month waiting period before the change takes effect. At the time, the law was presented as a correction to an outdated, medicalised system. Criticism came immediately: among others, the UN Special Rapporteur on violence against women and girls, Reem Alsalem, wrote in a letter to Foreign Minister Baerbock that the law contains no safeguards against abuse by sex offenders and does not adequately address the needs of women and girls (source); the German government rejected the criticism.

Two cases that fuelled the debate

What had until recently been a largely theoretical debate took on a concrete form this year through two cases. In the first case, a far-right activist who had been finally convicted in July 2023 and sentenced to one year and six months in prison without a suspended part had their name and registered sex changed and then did not report to serve the sentence; suspicion arose that the change was connected to this (source). In the second case, a police commissioner from Düsseldorf had his registered sex changed to female and then applied for a promotion; thanks to schemes promoting women, he would have moved up more than 40 places. The police headquarters doubted that a trans identity was the reason, opened disciplinary proceedings and imposed a promotion ban; the commissioner lost his urgent application before the Administrative Court of Düsseldorf and before the higher court (source). In both cases, suspicion arose that the change was primarily a means of achieving another goal; the law expressly does not require proof that the motivation lies in a trans identity (source).

The proposal: giving officials room to say no

The justice ministers of Saxony, Saxony-Anhalt and Thuringia — all three members of the CDU — therefore wanted civil registry officials to be given the power to reject a notification in cases of obvious abuse, for example for self-staging, personal gain or to ridicule the state, the group concerned or vulnerable groups (source). At the spring conference in Hamburg, the 97th Conference of Justice Ministers decided on 12 June 2026 that the law must clarify under which objective conditions registry offices can act in cases of obvious abuse, and asked the federal government for a legislative proposal; according to the Saxon minister, only objective and documentable circumstances may be examined (source). Supporters of the current law, such as Professor Heinz-Jürgen Voß, point out that a reflection period and a lock period for further changes already exist and that suspected cases are rare; journalist Anna Mayr wrote in Zeit Online that the proposal is well meant but unworkable, because the law has no objective definition of sex (source). For critics, that is precisely the heart of the problem: a law that bases identity entirely on self-declaration has no built-in way to distinguish abuse from a genuine request.